Pizza St. Petersburg, FL Style!

Feeding your family on vacation can be tough. Not only can dining get expensive, but it’s nearly impossible to agree on what you want to eat. But if there’s one thing almost everyone can agree on, it’s pizza! After a long day of visiting St. Petersburg attractions, there’s nothing better than getting a delicious pie to share with family and friends. And with endless ways to customize your order for different preferences and dietary restrictions, it’s sure to satisfy even the picky eaters of your group. 

The local pizza in St. Petersburg, FL, is some of the best in the state, and you’ve got plenty of locations to try it for yourself. Here are some of the most popular places to sample pizza near St. Petersburg, FL. 

Best Pizza St. Petersburg, FL

Fresh pizza being served
Photo from Shutterstock

Gianni’s New York Pizza

If you’re on the hunt for authentic New York style pizza, you can find it at Gianni’s New York Pizza. Start your meal with a classic appetizer like the handmade garlic knots, Mama Maria’s Meatballs, cheesy garlic bread, or a selection of wings. When it’s time to order pizza, you can customize your pie or choose a signature variety like The South Philly, The Great White, or Love American Style. They also offer gluten-free crust for those that prefer that option. Stromboli and calzones are also popular here! 

If someone in your group doesn’t want pizza, they can choose a sub, cheesesteak, salad, or pasta entree. Gianni’s New York Pizza is the perfect choice for St. Petersburg pizza whether you’re in the mood for something basic or more specialty. 

Paul’s Chicago Pizza

Paul’s brings genuine Chicago flavors down to the shores of St. Petersburg. Here, you can dine inside for a relaxing and welcoming environment, or you can get a “half-baked pie” to take back to your rental. Just pop it in the oven for 10 minutes and you’ve got dinner! 

The True Original Thin Crust Pizza is their most popular option, but they also offer two-topping French Bread pizzas. Guests can customize their pies to their liking or order specialty pizza like the Chicken Ranch Dip, Sam’s Special, or Buffalo Chicken. In addition to pizza, Paul’s offers subs, wings, and even homemade lasagna!

Fabrica Pizza

Fabrica Pizza brings the tastes of Naples across the pond to Florida. The pizza here is nothing less than top quality, from their hand-stretched dough to the tomato sauce with fresh local tomatoes. 

Fabrica specializes in thin crust, Neapolitan-style pizza. Of course, you can customize a pizza to your exact specifications, or you can go for a tempting menu option. Some of the most notable choices include the Margherita Pizza, Chorizo and Goat Cheese, and Buffalo Chicken. 

As far as other menu options, Fabrica offers a tempting assortment of salads and small bites like oven roasted meatballs and burrata caprese. And don’t leave without satisfying your sweet tooth! Try a scoop of one of their delicious seasonally-rotating gelato flavors or share a Nutella pizza with your family. 

Plan Your Visit

Don’t just take our word for it – stay at one of our fabulous Treasure Island, FL rentals and try these amazing restaurants out for yourself!

Other Italian in St. Petersburg


DalMoros Restaurant’s St. Pete location is situated in the heart of downtown St. Petersburg. The restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating, with a cozy and modern interior that perfectly complements its Italian cuisine. They are also available on many delivery apps and for pick up orders if you’d like to take your food back to your rental. 

DalMoros specializes in made-to-order pasta, which is cooked fresh right in front of you. Their menu features four pasta types to choose from paired with one of their eight different types of homemade sauces. Guests can then choose add-ins to customize their pasta even further. Be sure to save room for their tasty homemade tiramisu! The St. Pete location also offers catering services for events and parties. Overall, DalMoros is a great choice for Italian food in St. Petersburg that is both delicious and sure to please even the pickiest amongst your group. 

Stay with Sandcastle Realty

After a satisfying meal with the best pizza in St. Petersburg, FL, you’ll need a place to relax! That’s where Sandcastle Realty comes in. We’re a proud family-owned business offering impressive yet affordable accommodations for groups of all sizes. Stay at one of our Treasure Island beachfront rentals to wake up to stunning views and fall asleep each night to the soothing sounds of the ocean. Or maybe you’d like a pet-friendly Treasure Island rental to bring your furry-friend along for the excitement. 

Not sure which of our dozens of properties is best for your crew? Our team can help you decide on the right selection. During your stay, we can answer any questions you have about the features of your rental or things to do in the area. We can’t wait to welcome you to the shores of St. Petersburg!